Advertisement
Sleep Health

Nearly Three-Quarters of Surveyed NHS Shift Workers Screen Positive for Shift Work Disorder, New Study Finds

A cross-sectional survey of 443 healthcare shift workers at two NHS trusts found 71% met screening criteria for probable shift work disorder, with nurses, midwives, and women most affected

Hospitals cannot close overnight, making round-the-clock shift work a basic condition of healthcare jobs

A survey of healthcare shift workers at two large NHS Foundation Trusts in England has found that 71% screened positive for probable shift work disorder, renewing attention on the sleep toll of round-the-clock hospital staffing.

The study, led by Thavapriya Sugavanam and colleagues, was published November 5 in BMJ Open under the title "Prevalence and associated burden of shift work disorder (SWD) in healthcare shift workers in the UK National Health Service (NHS): a cross-sectional survey." Researchers recruited 443 shift workers from tertiary care NHS Foundation Trusts in London and the East Midlands between April and June 2025, screening them with the Shift Work Disorder Index, a validated tool that flags people likely to meet clinical criteria for the condition based on excessive sleepiness and insomnia symptoms tied to a non-standard work schedule.

Who Was Most Affected

Probable shift work disorder was not evenly distributed across the sample. It showed up more often among women, among registered nurses and midwives specifically, and among staff in higher NHS pay bands — band 5 and above, which covers more senior clinical roles with greater scheduling and shift-rotation demands. The survey did not assess participants' chronotype, the individual biological tendency toward morning or evening alertness that is known to influence how well a person tolerates night work, leaving that as an open variable in explaining who struggles most.

Shift work disorder itself is a recognized circadian rhythm sleep disorder in which a person's work schedule — rotating shifts, permanent nights, or early-morning starts — conflicts with their internal body clock closely enough to produce chronic insomnia during intended sleep periods alongside excessive sleepiness during intended wake and work periods. Unlike occasional fatigue from a single bad night, it is a persistent pattern tied directly to the work schedule itself.

A Figure That Needs Context

Outside experts, responding through the UK's Science Media Centre, were quick to flag an important caveat: the 71% figure comes from a self-selected group of volunteers who responded to a survey that was itself framed around sleep problems, which likely skews the sample toward people already experiencing symptoms. That means the finding cannot be generalized to the NHS workforce as a whole, or to shift workers broadly. The study's cross-sectional design is also a limitation — it captured a single snapshot in time, which can reveal associations but cannot establish that any one factor, such as pay band or job role, causes shift work disorder rather than simply correlating with it.

Even with those caveats, the researchers argue the pattern is consistent with a growing body of international research on healthcare shift workers, who are routinely exposed to rotating or overnight schedules as a basic condition of the job in a way that few other occupations require.

Why the Setting Matters

Hospitals cannot simply close overnight, which makes healthcare one of the occupational groups least able to avoid shift work entirely. That structural reality is precisely what makes the sleep health of nurses, physicians, and midwives a patient-safety issue as well as a worker-health one: sleep-deprived, circadian-misaligned clinical staff are more prone to attention lapses and errors during the overnight hours when staffing is often thinnest. Sugavanam is also listed as a contact on a separate, related feasibility trial (ISRCTN86601865) testing a sleep improvement program specifically designed for NHS shift workers, suggesting this survey may be laying groundwork for an intervention study rather than standing as a final word on prevalence.

What This Means for Patients

For patients, the main takeaway is indirect but real: the alertness and wellbeing of the nurses and clinicians staffing overnight and rotating shifts is not guaranteed, and healthcare systems that rely heavily on shift work carry some baseline risk of fatigue-related error that better scheduling practices and sleep support could help reduce.

For shift workers themselves, including those outside healthcare, the findings are a reminder that excessive sleepiness during work hours and insomnia during attempted sleep are not simply something to push through. Strategic light exposure, consistent sleep schedules on days off, and, when needed, evaluation by a sleep medicine clinician can meaningfully ease the burden of working against the body's internal clock — and employers, this study's authors suggest, have a role to play in making that support available.

Advertisement